Return to Home Page For The Spirit
[ March/April 2004 ]

Independent Spirituality

by Kimberly Chancey

…so many new organizations add more primary
leaders to the spiritual community.

In seeking freedom from imposed guidelines and principles of organized church affiliations, many groups of individuals worldwide have established independent churches and spiritual organizations. These new organizations are not connected or formally recognized by larger, established churches.

Father Tony Begonja describes this independent movement as “born of pain and ashes.” It is “a healing place… created by wounded healers in the power of the Holy Spirit.” Utilizing an “amazing variety of theological learning, forms of church structure, rules of internal discipline, and patterns of liturgical worship” the movements brings about “intimately small faith communities and house churches.”

Some of these organizations have been self starting, or spiritually entrepreneurial. Some were created by splits from other denominations, while others sprang from abandoned members stranded by political maneuverings of parent churches. Some groups started when people were dissatisfied with other locally available options, or those who never found a comfortable, traditional church home. Some groups have grown from powerful workshops or study groups whose members found such valuable support from each other that they expanded the traditional study format. There are even Internet-based, distance-worshipping opportunities.

Many people attracted to these new groups love the intimacy of smaller churches. A satisfying depth of community starts to emerge from within each group. People also love the fluidity of the less restricted organization, freed from dogma that can dominate more structured groups. The new organizational structures allow the groups to make decisions, change direction and adapt quickly. They may also immediately focus available energies upon a given task without starting a major strategy...or worse, establish a committee. While freed from complex leadership structures and committees, everyone who comprises the group is actually central in leadership. Everyone becomes an elder – and the worship team – and the prayer committee – and management. Such inclusion is a powerful dynamic for any group of people, particularly one with spiritual focus. As author Ralph Moore states, “start-up churches can reach more groups in need than regular churches. They're more flexible and can be more targeted.” One factor contributing to the growth of the independent movement is that so many new organizations add more primary leaders to the spiritual community. With the trend in spirituality, focusing on personal and independent relationships with Spirit, the movement allows more individuals to experience these roles and responsibilities. It also allows for more freedom of expression.

However, most leaders of these organizations recognize the fragility of the organization. Even small fluctuations in attendance or participation by even one member can alter the dynamics of the group.

One consequence of the independent movement is the manifestation of “Ordination Ministries.” These groups’ only declared purpose is to provide “legal” certification to ministers. One of the most well known is the Universal Life Church.

In 1974, the Universal Life Church sued the United States government regarding their right to have a tax-exempt status. When the judge ruled on this case, he also addressed the question of mail-order ordination, independent church charters, etc. The Universal Life Church performed a great service to all non-traditional ministries by fighting this case in court and eventually winning.

The following is excerpted from the court's decision in this case (the Universal Life Church is referred to as Plaintiff):

"...an Honorary Doctor of Divinity is a strictly religious title with no academic standing. Such titles may be issued by bona fide churches and religious denominations, such as plaintiff, as long as their issuance is limited to a course of instruction in the principles of the church or religious denomination... The statute is silent as to recognized honorary titles conferred for some meritorious recognition."

The court then addressed the issue of whether the ordination of ministers, granting of church charters, and the issuance of Honorary Doctor of Divinity certificates are substantial activities which do not further any religious purpose. The following is excerpted from the court's decision:

"Certainly the ordination of ministers and the chartering of churches are accepted activities of religious organizations... The fact that the plaintiff distributed ministers' credentials and Honorary Doctor of Divinity certificates is of no moment. Such activity may be analogized to mass conversions at a typical revival or religious crusade."

The part of the court's decision that guarantees the legality of various, non-religious ordinations states:

"Neither this Court, nor any branch of this Government, will consider the merits or fallacies of a religion. Nor will the Court compare the beliefs, dogmas, and practices of a newly organized religion with those of an older, more established religion. Nor will the Court praise or condemn a religion, however excellent or fanatical or preposterous it may seem. Were the Court to do so, it would impinge upon the guarantees of the First Amendment."

Ordination Ministries are sometimes referred to as "mail-order ordination services." As such, they provide a service and fill a need. However, they are not churches. They don't have a church membership beyond their own records of ordination, or certain "associations" of clergy, membership to which they charge a fee. In all fairness, they don't claim to be churches. They are, in fact, exactly what they claim to be: "Ordination Ministries.”

Congregations should be aware of the motivations, credentials, and qualifications of individuals intending to become leaders. To be successful, individuals interested in starting an independent organization may benefit from the following guidelines.

  • Protect your personal time and family. Don’t over commit.
  • Leaders must be flexible and original thinkers. If the group’s community is to survive over a period of time, a strong support group must develop.
  • In addition to a strong mission, the group must hold a strong vision of Spirit.
  • Financial Responsibilities: Prepare both an operational and opportunities budget. Wise spending habits with emphasis on opportunities and light on operational commitments will allow the organization to grow. In the beginning, there should be no big capital outlays. Think temporarily until the organization has the foundation to support the material possessions. Ministry is more important than buildings.
  • The most critical element to success is meaningful services that spark faith and hope in the member’s experience. Services should teach by example the goals of the church. For a congregation to grow, the organization must be responsive to individual needs.

Reverend Kimberly Chancey is an Anchorage area scientist, researcher and teacher. She conducts the Anchorage Community Spiritual Gathering, based on the belief that Universal Truth lies in the unification of Human Understanding.